Mid-Season Goalkeeper Review

Having descended into the quagmire of defensive metrics and never really returned, I thought it was about time to break my 2016 duck and publish something. Given that I occasionally spot people arguing in obscure forums pointing at the last iteration, I thought it was time to update my keeper ratings:

Keeper Mins Shots Saves Goals Save % Expected Saves ± Expected Average Difficulty Rating
Mark Bunn 188 6 5 1 83% 3.87 1.13 35.56 129.32
Fraser Forster 188 1 1 0 100% 0.86 0.14 14.45 116.89
Michel Vorm 94 1 1 0 100% 0.86 0.14 14.06 116.36
Karl Darlow 94 4 3 1 75% 2.62 0.38 34.53 114.56
Paulo Gazzaniga 187 11 8 3 73% 7.07 0.93 35.72 113.14
Alex McCarthy 565 34 29 5 85% 26.28 2.72 22.70 110.34
Sergio Romero 375 9 7 2 78% 6.47 0.53 28.14 108.24
Darren Randolph 286 12 8 4 67% 7.43 0.57 38.08 107.67
Adrián 1790 89 69 20 78% 64.11 4.89 27.96 107.62
Joe Hart 1871 60 46 14 77% 43.38 2.62 27.71 106.05
Hugo Lloris 1963 67 51 16 76% 48.10 2.90 28.20 106.02
Jack Butland 1972 100 78 22 78% 73.66 4.34 26.34 105.89
Declan Rudd 751 40 28 12 70% 26.51 1.49 33.73 105.63
Petr Cech 1967 86 68 18 79% 66.03 1.97 23.22 102.99
Kelvin Davis 95 7 5 2 71% 4.87 0.13 30.43 102.67
David de Gea 1591 64 46 18 72% 44.98 1.02 29.72 102.27
Heurelho Gomes 1948 83 60 23 72% 59.92 0.08 27.80 100.13
Thibaut Courtois 997 52 36 16 69% 35.99 0.01 30.79 100.03
Costel Pantilimon 1599 103 71 32 69% 71.01 -0.01 31.06 99.99
Kasper Schmeichel 2079 86 60 26 70% 60.21 -0.21 29.99 99.66
Artur Boruc 1604 62 38 24 61% 38.25 -0.25 38.31 99.35
Tim Howard 2069 107 75 32 70% 77.08 -2.08 27.96 97.30
John Ruddy 1316 63 38 25 60% 39.45 -1.45 37.37 96.31
Wayne Hennessey 1498 50 33 17 66% 34.45 -1.45 31.11 95.80
Tim Krul 754 49 33 16 67% 34.61 -1.61 29.36 95.34
Lukasz Fabianski 1979 85 56 29 66% 59.45 -3.45 30.06 94.19
Vito Mannone 376 23 15 8 65% 15.94 -0.94 30.69 94.09
Boaz Myhill 2077 92 63 29 68% 66.98 -3.98 27.19 94.05
Simon Mignolet 1889 65 42 23 65% 44.66 -2.66 31.29 94.04
Robert Elliot 1224 63 42 21 67% 44.82 -2.82 28.86 93.72
Willy Caballero 187 17 12 5 71% 12.83 -0.83 24.55 93.55
Asmir Begovic 1079 50 33 17 66% 35.75 -2.75 28.50 92.31
Brad Guzan 1897 99 64 35 65% 71.53 -7.53 27.75 89.48
Maarten Stekelenburg 1599 49 30 19 61% 34.38 -4.38 29.83 87.26
Jordan Pickford 93 11 7 4 64% 8.10 -1.10 26.40 86.47
Adam Federici 422 24 11 13 46% 13.16 -2.16 45.15 83.56
Adam Bogdan 93 5 2 3 40% 2.90 -0.90 42.03 69.00

So many narratives, so little time:

  • If only they’d dropped Guzan sooner – Bunn in his tiny sample has risen to the top of the class. Similarly, Southampton have finally got Forster back again and they too aren’t looking back.
  • Tim Howard isn’t that bad, get over it.
  • Petr Cech isn’t single-handedly winning Arsenal the title, get over it.
  • Jordan Pickford didn’t have the best of times deputising for Costel Pantilimon, the mathematical definition of the average goalkeeper.
  • Artur Boruc has slowly clawed his way back, and Bournemouth are no longer conceding every time their opponents so much as look at the ball.
  • Someone needs to rescue Alex McCarthy, he should have been going to the Euros this Summer.
  • Adrian is a pretty solid number 1 given the minutes under his belt.

Anyway, apologies for the wait. Lots of stuff I can’t talk about is going on behind the scenes, but there will be some cool stuff up here soon enough. Well, hopefully.

Mid-Season Goalkeeper Review

6 thoughts on “Mid-Season Goalkeeper Review

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s